Nearly Relevant

Nonsense, Fiction, and Miscellaneous Things

'Ball of Fat'¹ is the English translation of a short story title written by the French author Guy de Maupassant. The French is Boule de Suife. Ball of fat is the nickname of the story's protagonist. So nicknamed because she is, although pretty, fat and has, I imagine, a rotund shape. I'm glad I read the story. It was the first thing I've ever read by Guy de Maupassant and it's a famous story.

I can't say I'd recommend the story though. I think the story is mostly famous because the author shows sensitivity and some quite good descriptive abilities. I would recommend it for someone who has an interest in the writing of Guy de Maupassant or even an interest in fiction writing in general, but not for someone looking for an entertaining or emotive story. Basically, the story seems to me to be about the craft of Guy de Maupassant's writing rather than characters, events, and themes. Reading it is sort of like seeing the beams and supports of a building rather than the architectural design or facade. That 's my impression of the story.

Now we get to the strange part. There is a theme in the story. That theme deals with sacrifice. Not one review or analysis of the story that I looked at mentioned anything about the nickname 'ball of fat' as being an allusion to anything. It was as if ball of fat had no meaning. Imagine this; you're introduced to a brother and sister with this introduction, 'Hi, my name is George, this is my sister Ball of Fat.' Then having been introduced you say to yourself, 'That's kind of weird, but I guess it's just because she's sort of fat.' Then you move on to the Hors'Duerve table without any further thought to the name Ball of Fat. Well, I can't believe that there's nothing more to that name.

What more is there? Well, has no one heard of a sacrifice of a FATTED calf? Fatted calf - Ball of Fat!?

I think this story's theme is sacrifice as payment to a greater being. That's basically what happens in the story, but not one review mentions anything about the name Ball of Fat alluding to a sacrifice of a fatted calf or similar. Some do mention sacrifice as a theme, but it's the kind of sacrifice which is a self-sacrifice rather than a sacrificial offering. Those reviews mention a self-sacrificing choice of the character. I don't believe, thematically speaking, that self-sacrifice was de Maupassant's intended meaning. A sacrificial presentation as a consecration to a greater being is a more apt description of the theme than is the alternate interpretation of Boule de Suif's self-sacrifice.

I really am exasperated by this omission. Of course I didn't do a thorough search of the reviews but I would have thought such an obvious allusion would have been mentioned in most reviews right off the bat. But, nothing. Call me wrong or crazy, but don't call me disengaged.

¹Boule de Suif, Guy de Maupassant, http://www.readbookonline.net/readOnLine/453/, www.readbookonline.net

Posted: Monday, January 2, 2012 with 344 comment(s).

Categories: Stories, Books, and Authors,

Tags: 'Ball of Fat',

Report Abuse

Navigation

Home: Nearly Relevant RSS

Blog Search

Tags

robinson crusoe sailing youth literature zaniness DANIEL DEFOE repentence Mark Twain A CONNECTICUT yANKEE IN kING ARHUR'S COURT HAITI Pat Robertson Rush Limbaugh The Red Badge of Courage Henry Fleming Stephen Crane Don Quixote Knights Honor Stonehenge Li'l Stonehenge ColorPix® colors text background scam email get rich quick Veteran Veteran's Day Nov. 11 Short story Guns policies Poem Spring Seasons Flowers Woods huMor weaTHerMen America joke cows hurricane Irene hurricane preparedness story adventure marooned true accounts Nonsense humor stupid politics 2012 elections The Confetti Machine student stress bluster 'That Evening Sun Go Down' William Faulkner Piano Man brick books Herman Melville Moby Dick reading 'Ball of Fat' Anton Chekhov The Corrections Tomatoes Opuscule 2 idiocy Walks with Men bibleread2013 Hamlet Willa Cather Brian Turner Abelard and Heloise Letters Joseph M. Marshall III card game weird 'The Catcher in the Rye' J.D. Salinger The Sun Also Rises Ernest Hemingway Cormac McCarthy The Road 'Waiting for Godot' 'Orlando' Virginia Woolf John Hawkes Harold Bloom Oliver Twist Charles Dickens The New York Trilogy Paul Auster Truman Capote 'Breakfast at Tiffany's' Writing Errancy: Outcasts_Capitalism_and_Mobility Alberto Lopez Cuenca Denis Johnson mastering english E Minus web world wide web Intermission Vasim and Savim NoLie Scam email